Posted: 6/11/2012 6:26:28 AM |
Views:481
CGC vs XXXPHOENIX grading contest PART 7 : 58 books just graded!
Hello to everybody!
CGC just finished grading 58 books....let's compare their grades with my forecasts!
MANY MONTHS AGO I submitted 58 MODERN books to CGC...As soon as I receive them I will add them to my numerous registry sets.
Most of these come from my personal collection. They were all purchased as NM books before the CGC era...Anyway you can easily guess how hard it is to build a high grade comic book collection with the unique&only option of buying my books via (air)mail... to ITALY!
You can't imagine how many dealers just throw mint books in padded envelopes without further protection...
This is what I got! 27X 9.8 , 12X 9.6 , 4X 9.4, 7X 9.2, 4X 9.0, 1X 8.5, 2X 8.0, 1X 6.5 .
As usual most of my forecasts were pretty exact and remained in a +/- .2 range in comparison to CGC grading standards...with few unexplainable exceptions (check the *).
I will keep in my collection all books graded 9.4 or higher and few of the 9.2.
TITLE ISSUE FORECAST CGC
Alpha Flight 4 9.4-9.6 // 9.6
Alpha Flight 5 9.6-9.8 // 9.8
Alpha Flight 6 9.6-9.8 // 9.2
Alpha Flight 10 9.4-9.6 // 9.8
Alpha Flight 11 9.4-9.6 // 9.6
Alpha Flight 13 9.4-9.6 // 9.6
Alpha Flight 17 9.4-9.6 // 9.2
Alpha Flight 24 9.6-9.8 // 6.5 *ARGH!
Spider-Man 2 9.6-9.8 // 9.8
Spider-Man 2 9.6-9.8 // 9.8
Spider-Man 3 9.6-9.8 // 9.0 *WHY!?
Spider-Man 4 9.6-9.8 // 9.8
Spider-Man 4 9.6-9.8 // 8.5 *WHY!?
Spider-Man 5 9.6-9.8 // 9.8
Spider-Man 6 9.6-9.8 // 9.8
Spider-Man 7 9.6-9.8 // 9.8
Spider-Man 8 9.6-9.8 // 9.8
Spider-Man 9 9.6-9.8 // 9.8
Spider-Man 10 9.6-9.8 // 9.8
Spider-Man 11 9.6-9.8 // 9.8
Spider-Man 12 9.6-9.8 // 9.6
Spider-Man 13 9.6-9.8 // 9.8
Spider-Man 14 9.6-9.8 // 9.4
Spider-Man 15 9.6-9.8 // 9.0 *WEIRD
Spider-Man 16 9.6-9.8 // 9.8
Spider-Man 17 9.6-9.8 // 9.8
Spider-Man 1 GOLD 9.6-9.8 // 9.8
Spider-Man 1 POLY 9.6-9.8 // 9.4
Spider-Man 18 9.6-9.8 // 9.8
Spider-Man 19 9.6-9.8 // 9.8
Spider-Man 20 9.6-9.8 // 9.8
X-men 2 9.6-9.8 // 9.8
X-men 3 9.6-9.8 // 9.8
X-men 4 9.6-9.8 // 9.8
X-men 5 9.6-9.8 // 9.8
X-men 6 9.6-9.8 // 9.6
X-men 7 9.6-9.8 // 9.6
X-men 8 9.6-9.8 // 9.8
X-men 9 9.6-9.8 // 9.8
X-men 10 9.6-9.8 // 8.0 *OPS!!!?
X-men 11 9.6-9.8 // 9.6
X-men 13 9.6-9.8 // 9.0 *ARGH! POLIBAGGED book
X-men 14 9.6-9.8 // 9.2 *ARGH! POLIBAGGED book
X-men 15 9.6-9.8 // 9.0 *ARGH! POLIBAGGED book
X-men 16 9.6-9.8 // 9.2
Amazing Spider-Man 300 8.0-8.5 // 8.0R Restoration includes: small amount of color touch on cover. BOTTOM EDGE TRIMMED. *WHAT THE *** ...restored????
Amazing Spider-Man 313 9.2-9.4 // 9.2
Amazing Spider-Man 331 9.4-9.6 // 9.8
Amazing Spider-Man 666 9.4-9.6 // 9.6 ITALY COMICS
Amazing Spider-Man 666 9.4-9.6 // 9.4 ITALY COMICS
Captain America 253 9.2-9.4 // 9.6
What The 1 9.4-9.6 // 9.2
Spider-Man Unlimited 1 9.4-9.6 // 9.4
Fantastic Four 243 9.4-9.6 // 9.6
Fantastic Four 248 9.6-9.8 // 9.6
Fantastic Four 251 9.4-9.6 // 9.6
Fantastic Four 256 9.4-9.6 // 9.2
Fantastic Four 258 9.6-9.8 // 9.8
FEDERICO
Please Note: Member contributed comments do not reflect the views of the Certified Collectibles Group. View Full Disclaimer >