Presidential $1 Error Coins: James Monroe
Posted: 3/11/2008 by
This article is part of our series on Presidential Error Coins, and focuses on the 2008 James Monroe Dollar.
There is no doubting that a great number of collectors continue to search through rolls of Presidential Dollars looking for error coins. Take, for example, this evidence: the coins were released on February 14, 2008, and NGC has already received a handful of submissions of error coins. While the earliest issues of the series were found without edge lettering, the more recent issues do not exhibit this error in abundance (if at all).
Instead, NGC is seeing different sorts of errors, which are as a general rule much more scarce. For example, NGC has certified a few James Monroe $1 edge lettered planchets. These are coin blanks (technically planchets), prepped for minting, that were never struck but passed through the edge lettering machine only. Depending on the settings of the edge lettering maching, this can result in a few possible outcomes, the most desirable of which is a "blank coin" showing full edge lettering.
If they’re not struck, how do we know that these coins are James Monroe dollars? Simple. The date 2008 appears as part of the edge lettering, and these coins were released early in the year. The next coin in the series that will be dated 2008 is the John Quincy Adams, and that coin is scheduled for release on May 15. Until that coin is released, NGC can designate 2008 edge lettered dollar planchets as (JAMES MONROE). After the release of the John Quincy Adams dollars, edge lettered planchets dated 2008 will not be attributed by President at NGC. Thus, only the first coin issued each year is eligible for such attribution.
Edge lettered planchets essentially come in two varieties, fully edge lettered and partially edge lettered. Edge lettering is weak on all edge lettered planchets because they have not been struck to their full diameter (as constrained by the collar). After upsetting, the planchets are fractionally smaller in diameter than their final struck dimensions. Because of their smaller size, the edge lettering is applied under less pressure and can be weak. This may also cause the edge lettering to be only partial. Alternatively, a planchet can get hung-up in the edge lettering machine, and only partial lettering may be imparted. This type of partial edge lettering has been seen on a number of struck Presidential $1 Coins.
An edge lettered Monroe $1 blank planchet. Click to enlarge
This segmented image of an edge lettered Monroe $1 blank planchet shows an exploded edge view,
and the edge lettering is visible. Click to enlarge
The date portion of edge lettering on a Monroe $1 planchet. Click to enlarge
A portion of edge legend on a Monroe $1 planchet. WE of IN GOD WE TRUST is clearly visible. Click to enlarge
An NGC-certified 2008 P (JAMES MONROE) $1 EDGE LETTERED PLANCHET. Click to enlarge
An NGC-certified 2008 (JAMES MONROE) $1 PARTIALLY EDGE LETTERED PLANCHET.
The mint mark is not visible on this example, and therefore this information is not included on the certification label. Click to enlarge
In addition to the errors described above, NGC has also certified a Monroe $1 Coin missing clad layer. Presidential dollars are composed of the same three-part clad layers as the Sacagawea dollars. Planchets missing an outer layer show one side in rich copper color, as the pure copper center of the coin is exposed. This bright red is a sharp contrast to the "golden" appearance on the other side of the coin, adding to the drama of this error. Because coins missing a clad layer are thinner than normal planchets, they show weakness in the design especially along the edge of the coin.
| The obverse of this Monroe $1 is missing its outer clad layer and shows the rich copper color of its core.
The reverse of this Monroe $1, missing obverse clad layer,
shows characteristic weakness around its rims. Click images to enlarge.
Yet another error type recently encountered on the Monroe Dollar is PARTIAL EDGE LETTERING. This occurs when the coins "slip" as they are run through the edge lettering machine and may be accompanied by weak edge lettering or improperly spaced edge lettering. In some cases these errors are accompanied by Mint-caused damage as the coins get "hung up" in the edge lettering machine. The example illustrated below does not show this damage but portions of the lettering are faint.
Obverse of Monroe $1 with exploded edge view showing the partial edge lettering.
Notice that porion of the edge lettering are absent including most of E PLURIBUS UNUM. Click to enlarge
Close up of the rims of Partially Lettered Edge Monroe $1, showing weakness on date and part of E PLURIBUS UNUM. Click to enlarge
Stay tuned for updates and NGC articles on other coins in this series.